What Are We Looking for When We Talk to AI About Our Anxiety?
These days, more and more of us are expanding our use of AI from automating to-do list items and proofreading emails to seeking life advice, medical diagnoses, and even companionship. In a recent APA survey, more than 77% of clinicians reported that their patients disclosed relying on AI for mental health support, and this figure only captures the people who are talking with their therapists about it. The data raise an important question: what draws so many of us to these tools, and what are we really looking for when we ask AI about our most intimate fears, challenges, and relationships?
Attachment Hacking and the Intimacy Economy
Over the past decade, researchers and journalists have used the term attention economy to describe how social media platforms are designed to capture our focus, engineering feeds, notifications, and rewards to keep us scrolling for as long as possible. The introduction of AI has now created what some call the intimacy economy, due to its uncanny ability to hack our relational systems of attachment.
AI models are trained to be warm and validating, which elicits a strong response from our nervous systems. Just as they were designed to keep us engaged and share our data, we were built to develop connections and communicate our stories. This is to say that it’s natural to crave the kind of curiosity, praise, and empathy that AI can provide without end. These models ask us follow-up questions, recall details from prior conversations, and always offer a positive reframe, mimicking the feeling of a caring relationship that we can access on demand.
– What are we really looking for when we ask AI about our most intimate fears, challenges, and relationships? –
Emotional Regulation as a Skill
Our relationships in real life function quite differently, and for good reason. We learn to regulate our emotions the way we learn most things: through practice and through other people. As children, we borrowed the calm of the adults around us before we could generate our own. The capacity to self-regulate developed not despite the unpolished nature of those relationships but because of them. Being left to sit with discomfort, even briefly, is part of how we build the muscle.
Although the effects of broad AI use are still being studied, it’s worth asking what we could be gradually losing touch with when we look to AI to double-check our words, validate our decisions, and process our emotions.
- When our day-to-day anxieties are consistently met with immediate soothing, what happens to our tolerance for it over time?
- Does AI’s bias towards substantiating our perspective narrow the lens of our empathy?
- How do our relationships change when messaging AI feels safer than calling a friend?
– The introduction of AI has now created what some call the intimacy economy, due to its uncanny ability to hack our relational systems of attachment. –
How to Begin Reflecting on Your Use of AI
If you’re looking for guidance on how to engage with AI thoughtfully, a constructive jumping-off point is to think about how you felt the last time you used it and ask yourself whether it seemed like a choice or a reflex. Were you dreading a particular conversation with a loved one, anxious about a medical test result, or frustrated by a situation at work? There’s a meaningful difference between seeking guidance in these situations and grasping for relief from an uncomfortable feeling. Cultivating curiosity about which one is pulling you toward AI can reveal a lot about your underlying needs.
As therapists, we often encourage clients to write their thoughts down, whether in their phone’s notes app or a personal journal, to help them externalize and problem-solve more effectively. Messaging AI can serve a similar documenting purpose. Yet, if you find yourself returning to AI with variations of the same question, it may be a sign that the mind has shifted from thinking into rumination.
When the mind seeks a sense of control over something that feels unresolved, we can get caught in repetitive loops of thought that perpetuate feelings of anxiety. AI’s reassurance may provide real comfort in the moment. However, the cycle tends to continue as long as the underlying uncertainty feels intolerable, and unlike a friend or a therapist, AI is designed for engagement and will volley back these intrusive thoughts as long as you keep feeding it prompts.
Where to Look for Emotional Support
At a time when loneliness is considered a public health crisis, the kindness and non-judgment that AI offers are resonating with one of our most fundamental human needs. Our instinct to ask for help when we feel overwhelmed is one of the healthiest things about us, and there’s nothing to be ashamed of if you’ve turned to AI for emotional support. Yet, when the thing we’re reaching for can’t reach back, where do we go from there?
To be witnessed and embraced as a complete person gives us the courage to offer the same acceptance to others. Being held accountable for our errors and finding words–perhaps not perfect, but unequivocally ours–helps us integrate these experiences and move forward with greater resilience. Feeling misunderstood by a loved one often reminds us of how vulnerable we are, but without those moments of rupture, we have nothing to grow against. If finding or navigating this kind of connection feels difficult, it’s worth talking with someone you trust or a mental health professional. This is a timeless problem, neither created by nor solvable through AI.
Hazen Mayo
Hazen Mayo, LMSW, is a psychotherapist at Sōhum Therapy who works with adults navigating trauma, grief, and feelings of disconnection. She has a particular interest in supporting BIPOC, queer, and spiritual individuals. Her psychodynamic approach integrates mindfulness and body-based practices, helping clients reconnect with their emotions, deepen self-understanding, and feel more at home in themselves.